Daily Prompt: Confused

via Daily Prompt: Confused

(I know it was a couple of days ago – I never post things straight away!)

If the truth be told, we’re all a bit confused – that is, if we allow ourselves to be. Opinions are all around us – left and right, right and left, front and back, back and front. As many opinions as you would care to shake a stick at.

About what you ask? Just about everything! It’s almost fair to say that if you’re not confused, you’re not thinking! But confusion is not a pleasant place to be, so we tend to work our way out of it as quickly as we can.

I remember reading a book by Helen Garner (the First Stone) written back in the early nineties about a provocative event that had occurred at the time – something about a head of a university department being sacked for making a drunken pass at a female student. The book was compelling reading as Helen weighed in to it all, trying to sort out what had really happened and whether the punishment fit the crime.  She was concerned that, even if the guy was guilty, the backlash was way out of proportion to the crime, and driven significantly by feminist goals. Well, that put her fair and square in the sights of prominent feminists in Melbourne.

Months after the book had been released, and after responding to attack after attack on her views and the book’s contents, one commentator stated that the most endearing feature of her book, her uncertainty, had long since gone. She had had to defend herself and in the process became certain and dogmatic about a lot of things. Interestingly, many have still not forgiven her. Feminists of today routinely blame her for siding with the guy (which I don’t think she was doing), and for ascribing any kind of sexual power to the girl in question (which is fair enough but at least it should have been, even briefly, examined). My impression from the book was that she was simply trying to make sense of things objectively rather than apply a feminist pattern to the event, and that was what I appreciated most – not whether she was right in the end or not.

As I mentioned, she ended up becoming quite dogmatic in her stance. And that’s the problem. It would be easy to remain confused, to admit we don’t have the whole picture, but life moves on, and often we need to make a decision. So the confusion gets sorted, because it has to, and we may end up convincing ourselves that we really do know what we believe and why. But do we?

I know these blogs help me to work out what I believe on something. I start off with a topic, bend my mind to what I think, let things pour out, gain some insight, tidy up my blog to reflect that insight, and post it. But do I really know that I’m right?

No, of course not. I am much more clear in my thinking, and that’s a good thing. But woe is me if then decide that I KNOW the answer now. No, all I know is that I’m further down the road with that topic, and I would be wise to be as open as possible to being corrected or educated by someone or something else.

The fact is we can’t afford to remain confused. Life is busy – we have to move on. And that’s okay – that’s the way it should be. But let’s not hold on to our own views as if they are gospel truth. By all means let’s defend them against trite and weak arguments, but let’s not fall into the trap of defending them against all comers. That way lies bias, prejudice, and delusion. God forbid we let that happen – there’s already too much of that in the world as it is.

Advertisements

Author: Terry Lewis

I'm a guy in his 50's who thought it might be fun to write about day to day issues - the stuff that life is made of. It's helped me think and develop some deeper perspectives. I enjoyed it so much I thought I might start posting it in a blog, and here we are! I intend to mix it up as much as I can. I am a thinking kind of guy so the majority of my posts will probably have some kernel of truth or (hopefully) wisdom nestled in there somewhere. But I also hope to have some light hearted posts as well. Too much thinking can make life pretty dull! Anyway, hope you like it.

1 thought on “Daily Prompt: Confused”

  1. You nailed this one! There is a difference in being clear about what we believe and being right, beyond all doubt. Sadly, most people confuse the former with the latter, and that creates all kinds of unnecessary conflict.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s